People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Prices are unbeatable, food is good, and customer service is awesome. Love the people here, and the atmosphere brings back the nostalgia of an old school pizza joint which I love. Definitely recommend ”
“ Amazing Pizza I work at the Army Surplus Warehouse I always look forward to having lunch at Mr.Pizza ”
“ Super old fashioned and rustic place that still has that old charm. They have wonderful pizza and bread sticks for an amazing price. We are definitely going back for more date nights ”
“ Real Pizza crust crisp on the bottom, slightly but nicely charred on top for that nice NY pizza smokiness and flavor. No corporate pre made anything, this is real and its really good and a really good value. I love it. ”
“ My sons basketball team met there for an end of season get together. I thought it was great. The boys shared the 28 pizza which was really fun. The food was good and at a good price. The employees were accommodating for the rowdy 1013 ... ”
“ The best pizza Ive ever had! Ive always loved Mr Pizza, but they have really stepped their game up lately. Breadsticks are the best! ”
“ We just love Mr Pizza in Shelley. It is a warm family atmosphere with genuine care in their business and the community. When we have a large event we always go back to the Best Pizza in town! They support the community and I love to support them. The quality is outstanding and the service is remarkable and courteous. ”
“ Pizza is always great and at a fair price. Ive been coming here since I moved to Shelley in 02. Better value and quality than dominos. Support your locals ”
Menu
Combo Original Pizza
$8.003 Toppings Original Pizza
$7.002 Toppings Original Pizza
$6.001 Topping Original Pizza
$5.00Salad
$2.00
About
Mr Pizza Shelley
Welcome to Mr Pizza Shelley: A Slice of Nostalgia in Idaho
At the heart of Shelley, Idaho, nestled at 164 S State St, lies a gem for pizza lovers - Mr Pizza Shelley. This cozy pizzeria is not just about food; it's a nostalgic trip back to the charm of classic pizza joints. Known for its friendly atmosphere and unbeatable prices, Mr Pizza Shelley is where the community comes to gather, celebrate, and enjoy fresh, delicious pizzas.
Featured Menu Highlights
Mr Pizza Shelley offers a variety of mouth-watering options that cater to everyone. Here are some of the standout items:
- 1 Topping Original Pizza: Customize your pizza with a choice of toppings like sausage, pepperoni, bacon, olives, or beef for just $5.00.
- 2 Toppings Original Pizza: Enhance your experience with more flavor at $6.00.
- 3 Toppings Original Pizza: For the adventurer in you, savor a three-topping choice at $7.00.
- Combo Original Pizza: A delightful combination for just $8.00.
- Salads: Fresh and vibrant salads for only $2.00.
- Pizza Sandwich Italian: A flavorful twist on traditional pizza at $2.00.
- Lunch Special: Perfect for a quick bite at only $2.00.
- Garlic Bread: Add that extra touch with delicious garlic bread for just $1.00.
A Taste of Community
The reviews speak volumes about the ambiance and quality at Mr Pizza Shelley. Customers like Scotty & Andrea Thompson rave about the "unbeatable prices" and "awesome customer service," highlighting a sense of familiarity that makes each visit special. Similarly, Daniel Michalsky attests to the establishment's reliability for a quick lunch fix, always looking forward to the delight of a good pizza during his breaks.
For those seeking a nostalgic vibe, Brooke Eden Stewart describes the place as "super old fashioned," making it perfect for date nights where wonderful pizza and cozy atmospheres intertwine seamlessly. All Smiles adds that the crust is delightful - crisp yet perfectly charred, bringing a touch of New York pizza authenticity that fans appreciate.
Events are also made special at Mr Pizza Shelley. As Michael Packer notes, it serves as a great venue for celebrations, ensuring that good food and a lively environment are always on the menu.
Final Thoughts
Mr Pizza Shelley is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a community hub filled with warmth, camaraderie, and genuine happiness. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and enjoy a piece of the nostalgia. After all, in a world full of corporate chains and faceless eateries, finding a place like Mr Pizza Shelley is a slice of heaven.
For orders and inquiries, reach them at (208) 357-5560.
Book a table